close menu

How QE is changing the way investors behave

by Mike Abbott | Feb 26, 2015
  • For the last month or two, markets have been reacting to Mario Draghi’s somewhat expected announcement of Quantitative Easing (QE) in Europe. Whilst it’s too soon to judge how effective it has been in achieving its ultimate goals, one thing is certain: QE is changing the investment landscape.
    QE changing investors

    At first glance, this doesn’t seem like a very striking observation: when QE was initially launched, many predicted this. In fact, it’s what QE was designed to do – that is, restore confidence and change economic behaviour. A frail banking system is a threat to both citizens and businesses and leads to everyone battening down the hatches. Yet whilst the lift in business confidence and equity price levels was expected, the long game is very uncertain. We’ve never in history seen such a significant and prolonged monetary stimulus. We are in uncharted waters and our saviours are out of lifeboats!

    At the start of QE in the UK and US some schools of thought voiced fears of the expanded money supply triggering runaway inflation. Those of a Keynesian ilk suggested QE was not only helpful but urgent and necessary to restore confidence. It’s clear that in the case of the UK and the US, QE did prevent a lengthy recession if not a depression. In the case of Europe, I would argue that QE is very late but most necessary; and the austerity that has been applied so far has been harmful.

    So how does all this affect investor behaviour? The answer is a fundamental shift in the return characteristics of certain asset classes. In particular I refer to government bonds, corporate bonds and hedge funds. We’re living in an era of financial repression. This is when interest rates for savers are kept below the level of inflation to allow banks to provide cheap capital to businesses and individuals. It also reduces the cost of the government’s own debt.

    Financial repression

    Financial repression makes it much harder to generate income from a set stock of capital. It changes all the assumptions used when making investment and savings projections. QE floods the system with liquidity. That liquidity drives down the (forward looking) return on all assets (by driving up the price). That means one thing: retirement income falls short of expectations. At the same time, medical science and biotech are finding ways to make us live longer.

    The investor community is responding to this tension by drifting further up the risk curve. In order to provide the expected levels of return for clients, professional investors are forced to produce that return or find oblivion. That generates a dangerous form of short-termism where a large professional class of investors chase the same assets because everyone else is chasing them: not to do so risks making them lose out on the run. But everyone knows the run is QE driven and by definition temporary. It creates the conditions for an overreach and a severe correction. We’ve seen this in both equities and corporate bonds of late.

    This shift in focus leads the investor community to make purely tactical investment decisions based on second guessing policy makers and other market participants rather than on economic fundamentals. This paradigm shift created many new risks in the system.

    QE habit

    It was widely understood from the start that QE by itself could only act as a temporary relief to the economic difficulties we are suffering from. It could not be a long term solution. It was designed to give policy makers some breathing space to implement necessary structural economic reforms. But this risks being superseded by a sense that QE is the ‘new normal’: it is something investors are becoming reliant on in ever increasing doses to achieve their returns.

    But if people are concerned about how QE is affecting the markets in worrying ways, they are also alarmed at what might happen if the engine comes juddering to a halt. What if QE is suddenly withdrawn from a dependant market? We saw what happened when the Fed first tried to start ‘tapering off’ QE in the US. This scenario is known as the ‘sudden stop’: the most likely outcome would be an aggressive re-pricing of equities, as the current QE induced boom comes tumbling down. Equities are normally high risk high return assets but the current fragility of the system is raising that risk while reducing the potential return.

    Risk mispriced

    Those in the know are uneasy with this new reality. The plain, unvarnished reality is that low-risk assets are no longer low-risk, while high-risk assets pose a greater risk than ever.

    Savings rates need to be higher but middle class incomes have stagnated for decades. There are no easy solutions to this. In my opinion, retail investors would be well advised to focus on their capacity for loss, and to keep their investment time horizons firmly in mind.

    There’s never been a more important time to have an open and honest relationship with a trusted financial adviser.


    For more information on the topics covered in this post, or for any other wealth-related queries, you can contact us on +44 (0) 20 7759 7519 or email our wealth team.

    We are a professional services company that specialises in cross-border financial and immigration advice and solutions.

    Our teams in the UK, South Africa and Australia can ensure that when you decide to move overseas, invest offshore or expand your business internationally, you’ll do so with the backing of experienced local experts.

    • carrot-incentive-running-track
      UK pensions: Between a QROP and a hard place? Or is it a damp SIPP?
      Jun 21, 2018  |  by Niel Pretorius
    • piggy-bank-dollar
      What to do with your living annuity when you retire abroad
      Jun 11, 2018  |  by Niel Pretorius
    • house-london
      In the UK, mortgage inaction is pickpocketing thousands of homeowners
      Jun 07, 2018  |  by Bill Monty
    • Hand-currency-blue
      Saying goodbye to South Africa? Financial emigration can give you access to your RA before you turn 55
      Apr 13, 2018  |  by Niel Pretorius
    • Dubai_skyline
      Lessons learned on a trip to Dubai: South Africans take note
      Nov 10, 2017  |  by Mike Abbott
    • Piggy-banks-thinking
      Financial emigration: Transfer your retirement annuities out of South Africa
      Oct 20, 2017  |  by Niel Pretorius
    • row-of-houses-UK
      Bank of England overhauls mortgage affordability rates: Here’s what you need to know
      Oct 09, 2017  |  by Ian Henning
    • saving-money-investing-piggy-bank
      Limited company owners: What to do with your lazy cash
      Oct 02, 2017  |  by Ian Henning
    • house-home-loan-key-door
      Remortgage, anyone?
      Sep 27, 2017  |  by Marlon Borez
    • businessman-tightrope-risk-balance
      Group life cover: Why you should be worried about your lifetime allowance
      Sep 25, 2017  |  by Bill Monty
     
     

    South Africa

    Cape Town

    Regent Square
    Doncaster Road
    Kenilworth 7708 +27 (0) 21 657 2120

    Durban

    201 The Annex
    Ridgeside Office Park
    Umhlanga +27 (0) 31 536 8843

    United Kingdom

    London

    Castlewood House
    77/91 New Oxford Street
    WC1A 1DG +44 (0) 20 7759 7514

    Croydon

    5-7 Selsdon Road
    South Croydon
    CR2 6PU +44 (0) 20 7759 7581

    Australia

    Melbourne

    9 Yarra Street
    South Yarra
    VIC 3141 +613 (0) 8651 4500

    Sable International is a trading name of 1st Contact Money Limited (company number 7070528) registered in England and Wales. Sable International is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the UK (FCA no. 517570), the Financial Services Conduct Authority in South Africa (FSP no. 41900) and holds an Australian Financial Services License issued by ASIC to deal in foreign exchange (AFS License number 335 126).

    This site uses cookies, read more or close this notice.