close menu

UK contractors forced to overpay on VAT

by Kobus Van den Bergh | Apr 25, 2016
  • There is growing concern that the Flat Rate VAT system for contractors will end up forcing some small businesses to pay more VAT. Reports of HMRC ignoring verdicts of tax tribunals and forcing small businesses to pay higher VAT rates than required have begun to surface.

    The new “improved” Flat Rate VAT system

    HMRC requires Flat Rate VAT users to categorise themselves in terms of their occupations for VAT purposes. Unfortunately, the list of categories does not cover all possible occupations. As such, business owners have begun arguing with the taxman about which category they should be in. Most who apply nominate their business in the “other/unlisted” category. 

    The reason for this is two-fold. Firstly, many business do not clearly fall into a category on the list. In addition to this, the “other/unlisted” category also enjoys a 12% VAT rate. However, HMRC argues that many of these applicants should in fact place themselves in the “management consultant” category, which is subject to 14.5% VAT.

    According to the HMRC: “If you act as a consultant and you do not fit into another specific sector, you should choose management consultancy.” The revenue service then adds: “This sector is not restricted to businesses that fit the traditional idea of management consultancy.”

    Why the courts and the ATT disagree with HMRC

    UK courts and tribunals seem to disagree with the HMRC wish to lump most businesses into the “other” category. In a specific case, HMRC have explicitly stated that mechanical engineers fall under “architect, civil and structural engineer or surveyor”, which carries the higher VAT rate of 14.5%. However, a tribunal judge recently decreed that mechanical engineers belong in the “other/unlisted” category. The court reasoned that a mechanical engineer provides services linked to plant and machinery, not land. As there is no specific category for mechanical engineers, they would fall under “other/unlisted”.

    According to Niel Warren, head of the Association of Taxation Technicians’ (ATT) VAT sub-group, there have been other recent court cases that have confirmed that a business owner should use ordinary everyday words when determining their category. 

    "So an advertising consultant would never describe himself as a management consultant and a mechanical engineer would never describe himself as a civil engineer,” Warren explained. “In continuing to go against the courts views, HMRC’s thought process is flawed.”

    There are recent cases where HMRC has begun retrospectively collecting tax from contractors who have made an “unreasonable choice” when selecting their VAT category, exacerbating an already tense situation. The fact that HMRC appears to disagree with the courts over the categorisation of contractors is also worrying.

    The president of ATT, Michael Steed, gave voice to these concerns: “We feel it is the right time for HMRC to amend its guidance to accept that honest small business owners have adopted the correct category as intended by the legislation and to ensure people are not paying too much tax.

    “Furthermore, HMRC must provide clarity and certainty to scheme users that they will not be faced with the threat of receiving unexpected assessments or penalties for backdated VAT that, according to the letter of the law, should not be due.”

    Are you paying the correct amount of Flat Rate VAT?

    Evidence of accountants and their clients having to deal with HMRC investigations on the validity of their category selection is already surfacing. Some of these investigations have ended with the contractor being on the right side of the law, while others have resulted in in the contractor having to pay more tax.

    Whatever your current tax situation, you should check with your accountant to ensure you are correctly categorised for Flat Rate VAT. Visit our website or call us on +44 (0) 20 7759 7553 and we’ll make sure you’re paying the right amount of VAT.

    We are a professional services company that specialises in cross-border financial and immigration advice and solutions.

    Our teams in the UK, South Africa and Australia can ensure that when you decide to move overseas, invest offshore or expand your business internationally, you’ll do so with the backing of experienced local experts.

    • working-man-contractor
      Self-employment vs. contracting in the UK: What’s the difference?
      Oct 11, 2018  |  by Kobus Van den Bergh
    • growing-business
      Why your SME needs management accounting
      Oct 10, 2018  |  by Scott Brown
    • yes no cross tick
      HMRC’s employment status test continues to frustrate UK contractors
      Sep 24, 2018  |  by Kobus Van den Bergh
    • Money
      Leaving the UK? Get some extra cash by claiming your tax refund
      Sep 20, 2018  |  by Kobus Van den Bergh
    • Businessman-on-graph
      How you can stop worrying and learn to love outsourced accounting
      Aug 03, 2018  |  by Scott Brown
    • tax-deadlines
      Self Assessment deadline reminder! Second payment due end of July
      Jul 25, 2018  |  by Kobus Van den Bergh
    • magnifying-glass-contract
      IR35: Are you in or are you out?
      Jul 02, 2018  |  by Kobus Van den Bergh
    • Grabbing-money
      Don’t overpay on your tax! Make sure you’re on the right tax code
      Jun 28, 2018  |  by Kobus Van den Bergh
    • uk-flag-and-gavel
      IT contractor in the UK sues HMRC for £27,000 in landmark IR35 case
      Jun 18, 2018  |  by Kobus Van den Bergh
    • sky_pounds
      Why international entrepreneurs continue to choose the UK for business
      Jun 06, 2018  |  by Scott Brown

    South Africa

    Cape Town

    Regent Square
    Doncaster Road
    Kenilworth 7708 +27 (0) 21 657 2120


    201 The Annex
    Ridgeside Office Park
    Umhlanga +27 (0) 31 536 8843

    United Kingdom


    Castlewood House
    77/91 New Oxford Street
    WC1A 1DG +44 (0) 20 7759 7514


    5-7 Selsdon Road
    South Croydon
    CR2 6PU +44 (0) 20 7759 7581



    9 Yarra Street
    South Yarra
    VIC 3141 +613 (0) 8651 4500

    Sable International is a trading name of 1st Contact Money Limited (company number 07070528), registered in England and Wales. We are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the UK (FCA no. 517570), the Financial Services Conduct Authority in South Africa (1st Contact Money [PTY] Ltd - FSP no. 41900) and hold an Australian Financial Services License issued by ASIC to deal in foreign exchange (1st Contact Group - AFS License number 335 126).

    This site uses cookies, read more or close this notice.